A Reading Buddies Bookends

This last month was my first time participating in the Reading Buddies discussion run by Erin Reads and I’m already looking forward to next month’s read!  The adult fiction books which seem to be popular in the discussions she leads are definitely outside my usual reading bubble and at least with this first book, I really enjoyed that.  The March read was A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith.  When I first started carrying this book around to read I was worried someone would ask me what it was about because I wasn’t really sure how to sum it up nicely.  Then I looked up the genre for my genre-based reading challenges and discovered the wonderful German word, “Bildungsroman”, meaning a coming-of-age novel (or directly translated “formation novel”).  It makes me happy that there’s a word that so precisely describes what this book is about.

A Tree Grows in Brooklyn follows Francie Nolan as she grows up in Boston as part of a poor, second-generation, American family.  A major theme running throughout the book is Francie’s mother’s focus on seeing her children educated and giving them a better life than she herself had.  Francie’s own love of reading and education was to me one of the most endearing parts of the novel.  As a bibliophile, it’s hard not to fall in love with a precocious little girl who’s decided to read through every book in her library – what she thinks is every book in the world.  This is a small spoiler, but I think the fact that Francie eventually got her education was crucial to my enjoyment of the book.  I’m someone who prefers happy endings any way and to have someone so in love with learning be stuck working menial jobs forever would have just been too heart breaking.

I also loved Francie, and the author, for their interesting observations about people.  I found the spark notes chapter-by-chapter analysis actually talked a lot about these observations and the larger  themes the author was trying to convey and ended up reading that commentary along with the book.  Although some of the more literary among you might turn your nose up at the use of spark notes, I would highly recommend them.  Not instead of the book of course (sacrilege!) but as a supplement to make you take a step back and think about the bigger issues addressed in the book.

The story flowed very nicely, so much so that I had trouble putting it down, and I loved the authors writing style from the very first page.  As our host Erin wrote, the author’s tone is “straightforward, immediate, and no-nonsense, and yet through it she expresses so much.”  Although I agreed with Erin, this almost seemed like a contradiction to me – how could the book be so matter-of-fact and yet so engaging?  For me, I think the answer is that the book is about human nature and life.  There are beautiful bits, moving bit, sad bits, and heart-warmingly happy bits.  And while they’re all presented matter-of-factly as just part of life, they are no less beautiful, moving, sad or heart-warmingly happy because of that.

Finally, here is one of my favorite quotes: (Francie’s grandmother’s giving advice to her mother)

“Oh, and you must not forget the Kris Kringle.   The child must believe in him until the age of six.” … “Why? When I, myself, do not believe?”  “Because”, explained Mary Rommely simply, “the child must have a valuable thing called imagination.   The child must have a secret world in which live things that never were.  It is necessary that she believe.”…”The child will grow up and find out things for herself.  She will know that I lied.  She will be disappointed.” “That is what is  called learning the truth.”


A Tree Grows in Brooklyn – ★★★★☆ -Wonderful book about growing up and human nature.  Loved the writing style and the main character.  Definitely a book I would recommend.

Other Reviews:


Filed under Classics, Fiction, Historical Fiction

6 responses to “A Reading Buddies Bookends

  1. Pingback: Katie’s #18 #CBR4 Review: A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith « Cannonball Read IV

  2. terri3505

    I read this in high school and loved it!

    • I’d never heard of it before it was selected for the reading buddies discussion, so I was surprised it had it’s own spark notes. I definitely think it makes sense as a book to read in high school or for a book club, since there are lots of themes to talk about 🙂

  3. Thanks so much for participating in Reading Buddies! I’m glad it introduced you to a novel you ended up enjoying. I’m with you about Francie — how can you not love her after that scene in the beginning when she’s up on the fire escape with her pillow, book, and candy, hidden away in a tree… 🙂

    It never even occurred to me to look for Spark Notes for this one. In fact, I haven’t really thought about those things since high school. I bet they actually contain a lot of interesting stuff that I’d probably enjoy a lot more now, reading them voluntarily, than I did as a student!

    Finally, I really love what you wrote about reconciling matter-of-fact with engaging. Right on. I think you pinned down exactly what makes the novel work.

    It was a pleasure reading your insights on this one! Thanks again for reading along!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s